My sim has listed 3 active Romances (the fourth she said "let's just be friends) and before each new romance there was a notice "Matthew isn't sure he wants to continue this relationship", so she went back and rekindled the relationship. This happened after each new romance. Then, she cornered Matthew and asked him to marry her (I purchased the Master Romantic just before), and he agreed. So they got married, and she still has in her reputation "cheater", because everytime she goes to other guy's houses, they're not home when she arrives. So, she can't break up with them. One is Matthew's "Best Friend Forever", who is now divorced from Stella, who became my sim's "Best Friend Forever". Complicated. I'll have to purchase the "clean slate" because the guys are hard to contact.