Fishing Quest problem

[boatsm8]

I'm doing The Fisherman's Challenge quest with Marlon as my advisor. (he may not of been the right choice!) I'm supposed to try to catch a Mysterious Lobster that must take pity on me because I'm so unfocused that I can't catch anything else. I have let my focus meter get to nil and even negative while fishing the 5-6 fishing spots in the Docks area, but to no avail. Am I in the wrong spot? Do I have to reload a previous game and choose the other fisherman? Any help would be great!

[Lilygirl]

I got the lobster when I waited to fish until the option was red. When you click on the fishing spot, the option "Fish" has a coloured background the corresponds to your hero's focus and the likelihood they are of succeeding at the action. Green = high chance of success, Yellow = neutral, Red = low. Wait until it is red. It was about 3am and my hero was exhausted, hungry, and badly needed a drink (Drunkard Fatal Flaw).

[TheChronicR]

Wait till it shows red. After some time, a pop-up will notify you about the lobster.

[chrissie]

I found Marlon to be the best choice of advisor, I'm struggling slightly to complete this as I picked the wrong hero, my physician who has a legendary trait. At the moment, because he's friendly, I have him pick an argument with someone, it seems to be working.