The Sims 4 Star Wars Game Pack

It's Not What I Expected So Far

Sims 4 Star Wars Journey to Batuu Game Pack
A Sim wields a lightsaber in Star Wars: Journey to Batuu a Sims 4 Pack.

I'm a fan of Star Wars. I'm a fan of The Sims. I'm not a fan of them combined, at least not in the way they evidently have been forced together in the upcoming Sims 4 Journey to Batuu Game Pack. As more information has come out, my hesitation to be excited has gradually evolved into "this can't possibly please me".

Sims unrealistic expectations
This amazing world is from the gameplay trailer. Mine do not look like this. At all.

The idea's not bad at its core. Crossovers have happened before, and Journey to Batuu as depicted in the new Gameplay Trailer does seem to be a lively Star Wars world. But I know that the Sims are perfectly placed in that trailer. They aren't standing to eat in front of a television or shuffling constantly while I'm trying to record a scene at a table. They're all set up to be doing a variety things to make for a lively scene and when I get in the game, I am afraid the aliens will be acting like Sims for the most part except for a couple new animations.

Kylo Ren in Sims 4 Star Wars
Kylo Ren - a Sith - using the force. But don't get too excited, your midichlorian count's too low for this stuff.

Ok, but maybe the pack can redeem itself by introducing a new force-based skill or even a new Jedi/Sith Occult to let you wield a lightsaber and maybe you can learn some cool force powers from working with either the light or dark sides? I mean, both Rey and Kylo Ren are present in this pack. That was my only hope.

Sims in battle in Sims 4 Star Wars
If you can walk to the fridge without getting winded, you can probably wield a lightsaber idk.

It instead chooses to let you experience it as a normie in the Star Wars universe. Oh, I know. Most characters in Star Wars are totally normal people and that is what makes their heroics extraordinary. But it's hardly letting me live out my Star Wars fantasy by tying lightsaber ability to the fitness skill and calling it a day. My handiness will probably drive starship repairs. These are base game skills and in the case of fitness, extremely uninteresting and not impactful at all. Who knew that all you to do is complete a "Couch to 5k". Now you can wield a weapon that only a force-sensitive can use correctly in combat... without accidentally becoming an amputee, of course.

Missions for factions in Sims 4 Star Wars
Completing missions to earn standing with factions isn't bad, it'd be a lack of actual cool rewards that keep me from coming back to it.

The Journey to Batuu Pack's focus on missions to increase standing with the three factions gives me little hope that there will actually be interesting rewards or outcomes from siding with one over the other. The Sim in the gameplay trailer returns home to deck out her Willow Creek home in Star Wars inspired architecture and dances with her droid. If there were something a bit more interesting to show, now would be the time.. given over half the community is not just disinterested in this pack, but rather upset by its very existence.

Sims in Sims 4 Star Wars
Alien bartender doing tricks in Star Wars: Journey to Batuu

That frustration seems to come from a sense that they are not being listened to. People feel the game is in a bad place even as pack count climbs into the 30s. In the past we'd exhausted most of the 'wants' for things by the 10th Expansion pack, but here we have over $700 in content but yet are still missing basic things like cars, or being able to sit with your baby on the couch, or letting your children share a room with a bunk bed. Meanwhile, modders create functional-enough versions of these things.

Using handiness to repair a ship in Sims 4 Star Wars Journey to Batuu
My Sim's handiness can surely see me through this intergalactic adventure.

There is another factor as well. The Sims maintains a pretty tight release schedule, and every few months we are excited for the next big thing. When a pack like this comes out that many people are uninterested in, while so many good ideas are still floating out there, it makes people feel disappointed. The wait since Eco Lifestyle (a rather boring pack) and Knitting leads to an empty space where a cool Game Pack could've been.

Make a silly face to Stormtroopers in The Sims 4 Journey to Batuu Game Pack
I don't have the force, but I have the ability to make a silly face!

I've not even touched on the fact that this feels like it exists merely to market Disney's Galaxy's Edge attraction, or for EA to take advantage of the Star Wars IP in as many ways as possible while they still have the deal with Disney. If they were going to do this, letting us actually live out a Star Wars fantasy that we are playing a Jedi would have been the way to go. But because it's a corporate deal it was probably impossible to do the Star Wars pack that might have excited players like me. There are so many ways to go with something like this, but marketing Galaxy's Edge for Disney while simultaneously asking a $20 price tag was never going to go over well with the community. If you don't care about Star Wars, you'll have to wait.

Lightsaber in Sims 4
Am I on Batuu looking for Kyber Crystals to make a lightsaber, combing the beach, or checking pockets for loose change before I do laundry?

2020 has not felt like a great year for The Sims as a whole. Eco lifestyle was buggy on release. The vote for Knitting as a stuff pack didn't seem to be what most of the community wanted thematically, perhaps due to the way the vote worked out. Now we're getting a Star Wars pack. We really need some kind of victory because I feel that players are getting more upset these days than excited, and that's a shame. You do not have to look very far to see more and more players who are angry about gameplay depth and a buggy experience.

Who are the characters in sims 4 star wars
Many Sims Players have no idea who these people even are, but when you play this pack you'll learn all about these iconic Disney™ Star Wars™ characters.

I'm not yet playing this pack, and I won't get to experience it until the same time you do. I'm simply following the news and not excited about what I hear, because it seems like a letdown so far. If the pack manages to change my mind, I'm open to having it changed and will give it every opportunity to do so when I buy it to take it for a test drive. So far, slapping a coat of Star Wars paint on existing Sims ideas just doesn't seem like a very fun proposition for me.

How You Can Support The Site and Channel

If you like my sites and Youtube Channel, consider supporting me on Patreon to help me to continue. If you'd like to support my guides in another way you can use our Amazon link for your next purchase (if in the US). We also offer a paypal donate link so you can contribute directly.

Back to The Top


Check Out My Youtube Channel!

We now have a Youtube Channel with over 50 guides in video format to go along with the huge site I've already created. Check it out and consider subscribing if you like my style.


Add Comment

* Required information
2000

Comments (10)

Gravatar
New
Coryleasays...

I'm more of a Star TREK fan than a Star WARS fan, but I like science fiction in general, and I'd be happy to play a Star Wars pack if it looked good ... but this doesn't. Witch and Vampire were both life states that came in Game Packs -- rather than Expansion Packs -- so I don't see why the Star Wars pack can't have a Jedi life state!

Gravatar
Regular
Aurelia Auritasays...

I'm surprised that Carl obviously wasn't given the pack since other Game Changers got it, for example Vixella, who expressed excitement about some of the build skins being well suited to building outdoors, and Plumbella, who advised her followers not to buy the pack unless they're truly into Star Wars.

For many simmers including myself this pack was the moment their unhappiness became more relevant than their loyalty to the franchise.

Would it be possible to provide some information about the recent patch? Were there any important changes besides windows being stackable?

I'd love to know since at this moment, my game keeps crashing, (probably due to problems with mods that need to be updated, so it's my fault, not EA's) so it would reduce my discontent significantly if I knew that it was done in order to implement important and useful things.

As for Star Wars, I don't really like the idea of two franchises being mixed unless it's done really well, with a bunch of creativity. But since EA is keeping the DLCs self-contained, I can't think of many possibilities. Using special powers to actually improve the Sims world in ways that are completely new would be great, but difficult to implement, unfortunately.

Gravatar
Senior
Playalotsays...

A lot of mods and cc windows etc broke with this patch so I suggest heading back to the creators pages and taking a look. Chances are most of your mods and all cc windows you may use, will need updating.

Gravatar
New
Leroysays...

Carl's sims guides is certainly top 3 among known users of the sims and it shows ea's true colors in not sending him an early release. If you don't kiss their buts they will shun you. Kudos to Carl for keeping it honest as he always has. So glad we have him.

Gravatar
New
Seraphsays...

Reading between the lines of what I've seen from other reviews, this is a game pack that has:

-No new lots (the most excusable part of this whole thing)

-No new traits

-No new careers (since it seems like 'joining' one of the sides is not a career but a hobby - as though fascism or freedom fighting were part-time work)

-No new occults (easily the biggest miss - if this had let me make a Jedi sim, I'd be buying it)

-Essentially is a glorified stuff pack + map.

So, what I'm extrapolating here is that Maxis didn't really care much about this. Likely, this was a mandate from their corporate overlords, which probably came from their IP deal with Disney, to do something promoting Star Wars and Galaxy's Edge specifically. My guess is that because of this, and because they had to know their fanbase wouldn't give two wet slaps about this particular pack, they either:

-Phoned it in with as little added to the game as possible, so they could just get it done and get corporate off their backs, and go back to working on what they want to be working on, or

-Specifically made it as unimpactful on the core game experience as humanly possible, so that people wouldn't have even a remote possibility of having to deal with random aliens, stormtroopers, or Force-using townies.

I feel backed up in this assessment by the fact that most of the other game packs contained more impactful content. Careers, occults, maps, objects, traits, etc. Even the thinnest of the game packs added something that affected the rest of the game experience. This just doesn't seem to do that, at all.

I honestly hope people stop taking their frustrations out on Maxis and the Sims development team over this. They probably didn't have a choice in the matter. When the corporate overlord says 'jump', you don't exactly get to say 'no'. Not if you want to keep working.

Gravatar
New
Nephibissays...

I also wanted to be a Jedi/Sith, so thd absence of that is upsetting. I can be fine with a normal and saber as a rebel, but on the dark side I want to become a Darth and take over not work for Kylo Ren. I also hated the Eco and Knitting, but people wanted boring "realistic" stuff. A lot of people claim that is what they want. I do want cars, but I want Star Wars more (though with force powers). I'm not too pressed on cars, because they are just for travel, so they would have minimal use beyond nice to look at. I don't care for the baby stuff or bunk beds tbh. I had bunk beds growing up and don't see why people are so happy to get them.

Gravatar
New
parryottersays...

It's about realistic gameplay, not what you had in real life. I had a bunk bed too; that's wholly irrelevant. I want to create a LIFE simulation, which is what The Sims is supposed to be. This pack is so out of left field for what The Sims is, and it's poorly done on top of that. The only lot that's not a rabbit hole is the Cantina????? This patch broke EVERYTHING and it's for a pack I have zero interest in owning.

Gravatar
Regular
Zerosays...

Sorry but if you want REALISTIC how about stop playing games and actually live a REAL LIFE?

Gravatar
Regular
Zerosays...

This pack is nothing but your character going to a Theme Park the problem with this is that people thought they would be getting a REAL Star Wars based DLC. Who thought your character going to a Theme Park instead of the real thing was a great idea? I mean people play games and go to Theme Parks because they can't do the real thing so going to a Theme Park inside of a game is literally a double slap to the face. But they have to keep it realistic because that's what people want right

Gravatar
Regular
Aurelia Auritasays...

There are people on both sides and as far as I know, occults are frequently requested and they do fit in. However, Star Wars is not about a life state, but about a whole universe, so I'd love to get it as a spinoff like Sims Medieval. A Star Wars world to live in and in which it doesn't feel odd to run into strange looking beings on the streets. A theme park is not enough. It's too little for that enormous franchise. The people who prefer realistic gameplay were not the reason for the lackluster result of the pack, but the fact that Star Wars is too complex to fit into another franchise with a single game pack. And I believe that even a lot of the players asking for a realistic life sim could get excited about it if it was done well.

What about having a way to enable or disable content, like in TS3? So that in one save game, you can have Jedis and everything or perhaps turn Oasis Springs into a Star Wars neighborhood while keeping those odd guys out of the other? That might be a good way to make both sides happy and get more Star Wars stuff than a boring theme park.

Gravatar
New
Kyle Ksays...

Ya know I’m a huge Star Wars nerd and I’m a sucker for buying every pack just to expand the game in hopes that it gets better.... But you can’t even wield the force in this pack?!?!? Kidding!?! God I hope a modder can do something about that. Only two real Star Wars characters?? You can’t shoot a blaster!? The missions have no endgame or battle between factions!? Joke! Not even worth it for Star Wars fans and you can’t wield Kylos lightsaber?! Horrible!

Gravatar
New
Irishnanax6says...

i think it's a waste of $20!

Gravatar
New
Reynsays...

I think the game pack is more taking advantage of EA existing game assets that they have from other games, because I'm sure Covid-19 played havoc like it did for so many other things.

That said, its a pretty rubbish expansion overall and I don't feel it was worth my $20.

Gravatar
New
Karianne Harringtonsays...

I disagree. I keep hearing not good reviews. Im baffled by that. I love sims so much i got it tattooed. And i also love starwars. What did you expect? Well i appreciate what was developed and all the hard work they put into it. I love my droid. Using cheats to make my mermaid world and the other lands all starwars. The Batuu experiance was great and seeing the famous characters. When did the world get so snotty and demanding. Cause thats how your review sounds.

Gravatar
New
Delilahsays...

Not particularly interested in combining SW and The Sims (unless it was a really well-made total conversion perhaps), but I’m somewhat optimistic that this pack will give modders a means to keep sims from leaving any given worldspace on their own. Hopefully *if* such functionality is added, it’ll be in a basegame patch so you don’t need to buy an entire pack you’re not interested in for it.

On the other hand, I hope this doesn’t mean we won’t get something Into the Future-esque in the, well, future.



Search my Sims 4 Site

Support Us

Readers who use adblock or those who'd like to thank me for my efforts can now pledge $1/$5 monthly via Patreon. This helps a lot with server costs and provides some stability for my business.

Super Sim Checklist + Other News

Super Sim Text + Checklist and Video Guide! Here is my Super Sim Challenge Guide and Checklist to accompany my video guide to making Super Sims in The Sims 4 that you can view on Youtube.

This is inspired by a new series in which I start at toddler and gradually take on the major bonuses. Here's a link to the full playlist!

I now have a guide page to Tiny Living Stuff where you can learn about Murphy Beds, the new death, as well as the lot bonuses you'll receive if you manage to keep the size of your lot down with this new pack's Tiny Home Lot Type.

Let's Play Playlist

Super Sim Gameplay in The Sims 4

New I now have a guide to Making Super Sims in The Sims 4. Look for a text version within the next 72h. It won't have THAT much more info but it will help out as a checklist.

This was inspired by a series, "Let's Play a Super Sim" in which I start at toddler and gradually take on the major bonuses. Here's a link to each part for people who are interested. You can also see the Let's Play as a Playlist on Youtube.